Exploring South Carolina Redfish with Captain Johnny Mainero on the Wet Fly Swing Podcast

The Wet Fly Swing Fly Fishing Podcast, hosted by Dave Stewart, has become a trusted resource for anglers around the world. Whether you are into trout, steelhead, or saltwater species, Dave brings experts from every corner of the fishing world to share their knowledge, stories, and strategies. In episode 706, Dave sits down with Captain Johnny Mainero, founder of Blackwater Revival Guide Service, to discuss the thrilling pursuit of redfish in the unique waters of South Carolina.

For seasoned anglers or beginners, this episode is packed with insights into redfish behavior, fishing techniques, and what makes the South Carolina coastline a standout destination for anglers. Beyond redfish, Johnny also dives into the area’s opportunities for targeting species like sharks, speckled trout, and flounder.

Who Is Captain Johnny Mainero?

Johnny Mainero is a guide and angler with a deep connection to the waters of South Carolina. Based in Georgetown, he operates Blackwater Revival Guide Service, offering anglers the chance to explore iconic fisheries like Pawleys Island, Myrtle Beach, and Winyah Bay. His passion for the sport and extensive knowledge of the local ecosystem make him a standout guest on this episode.

Johnny's fishing philosophy goes beyond just catching fish. He emphasizes understanding the environment, respecting the ecosystem, and making the most of the experience. Whether you are poling a flat in search of tailing redfish or casting to schools of redfish in a shallow creek, Johnny’s approach blends science, technique, and artistry.

The Allure of Redfish Fishing in South Carolina

One of the focal points of the episode is the redfish, also known as red drum. These fish, with their bronze bodies and distinctive black tail spots, are a prized catch in the Southeast. Johnny describes the redfish as both challenging and rewarding to target, making them a favorite among anglers.

The South Carolina coast-particularly the areas around Pawleys Island and Winyah Bay-is home to a variety of habitats ideal for redfish, from tidal creeks to sprawling flats. Johnny explains how these fish use the tide to their advantage, moving into shallow waters to feed during high tide and retreating to deeper areas as the tide recedes. This movement creates predictable patterns that anglers can use to their advantage.

The Gear and Tactics You Need

Johnny and Dave dive deep into the gear and tactics best suited for redfish. Johnny emphasizes the importance of having the right rod and reel setup, recommending an 8-weight fly rod paired with a floating line for most conditions.

When it comes to flies, simplicity is key. Johnny’s go-to patterns mimic the natural prey of redfish, including shrimp, crabs, and baitfish. He highlights a few favorites, such as the EP Crab and the classic Clouser Minnow, which he adjusts depending on water clarity and light conditions.

Presentation is another critical aspect of redfish on fly. Johnny shares tips on reading the fish’s body language and adjusting your cast accordingly. A well-placed fly that lands softly and mimics the movement of natural prey can make all the difference.

South Carolina Offers More Than Redfish

While redfish take center stage in this episode, Johnny and Dave also touch on the other species that make South Carolina a fishing hotspot.

Speckled Trout: Known for their striking spotted pattern and thumping bite, speckled trout are another popular species in South Carolina. Johnny explains how these fish prefer deeper channels, particularly around areas like Pawleys Island, and how anglers can use topwater lures or streamers to catch them.

Flounder: South Carolina’s shallow waters, including spots near Myrtle Beach and Winyah Bay, also hold good numbers of flounder, a flatfish that offers a unique challenge. Johnny advises targeting flounder near structure, such as docks or oyster beds, where they lie in wait for passing prey.

New Additions for 2025: SHARKS!

One of the most adrenaline-filled experiences Johnny offers is shark fishing on a fly rod. South Carolina’s coastal waters, particularly in areas like Winyah Bay and Myrtle Beach, are home to several shark species, including blacktips and bonnetheads, which can be targeted on the fly. This type of fishing demands heavy-duty gear, including a 10- or 12-weight rod, a sturdy reel with plenty of backing, and wire leaders to handle the shark’s sharp teeth..

Johnny describes the thrill of sight fishing for sharks in shallow water, where their dorsal fins slice through the surface, creating an unforgettable visual. Once hooked, sharks put up a powerful fight, testing both the angler’s skill and stamina. While intimidating, Johnny emphasizes that targeting sharks on the fly is both safe and rewarding when done responsibly. It is an incredible way to push your skills and experience the raw power of South Carolina’s marine predators.

When to Fish in South Carolina

Timing is everything when planning a fishing trip to South Carolina. Johnny explains how seasonal changes influence fish behavior and what anglers can expect throughout the year.

Spring: As water temperatures rise, redfish become more active in feeding patterns. This is a great time to fish shallow flats and tidal creeks.

Summer: The warmer months bring consistent opportunities for sight fishing redfish on the high water flats. Early mornings and late evenings are prime times to avoid the heat.

Fall: Fall is considered the best season for fishing in South Carolina. Cooler temperatures and abundant food source make for excellent conditions across all species.

Winter: While sometimes cold, South Carolina can offer exceptional sightfishing for Redfish. Fish will move shallow into larger groups and the water clears.

Preparing for Your Trip

Whether you are a local or visiting from out of state, Johnny emphasizes the importance of preparation. Before hitting the water, do your research on local conditions, tides, and regulations. Hiring a guide, especially if you are new to the area or traveling in, can make a huge difference. Guides like Johnny not only put you on fish but also teach you the skills to succeed on your own.

Johnny also stresses the importance of conservation. South Carolina’s fisheries are a finite resource, and it is up to anglers to practice catch-and-release and follow ethical fishing practices to ensure the health of the ecosystem for future generations.

What Makes South Carolina Special

What makes South Carolina such a special destination for anglers? Johnny credits the state’s diversity of habitats, from salt marshes and tidal flats to estuaries and rivers. Areas like Pawleys Island, Myrtle Beach, and Winyah Bay offer incredible fishing opportunities and showcase the state’s natural beauty.

The state’s natural beauty is another draw. Whether you are casting against the backdrop of a golden sunrise or exploring hidden creeks surrounded by marsh grass, South Carolina offers an unforgettable experience both on and off the water.

Conclusion

Episode 706 of the Wet Fly Swing Podcast with Captain Johnny Mainero is a masterclass in saltwater fishing. Whether you are an experienced angler or just starting your fishing journey, the tips and insights Johnny shares are invaluable for anyone interested in targeting redfish, striped bass, speckled trout, or flounder in South Carolina.

Johnny’s passion for the sport and his dedication to conservation serve as a reminder that fishing is about more than just catching fish. It is about respect for the environment, learning from the water, and creating memories that last a lifetime.